Those who are sure when answering that "it does bring happiness", immediately present a list of frustrations of all kinds, which are only overcome by that "clinking clanking sound which can make the world go around". [Liza Minelli, in Cabaret, 1972]
They are criticized by those who respond otherwise: "Rich people can be extremely unhappy, in many situations where money can't help anything."
During one of these discussions, quite polarized, which I witnessed without taking a stance, an old lady supporting "yes, money brings happiness" arrogantly made a comment intended to exhaust the discussion:
"Okay, arguing with stubborn people is a waste of time! Therefore, in order only to make you happy, I proclaim your 'victory, suggesting that all the money eventually coming to your hands be transferred to my Swiss Bank account in Zürich. Good Bye, and BE HAPPY!!!"
During one of these discussions, quite polarized, which I witnessed without taking a stance, an old lady supporting "yes, money brings happiness" arrogantly made a comment intended to exhaust the discussion:
"Okay, arguing with stubborn people is a waste of time! Therefore, in order only to make you happy, I proclaim your 'victory, suggesting that all the money eventually coming to your hands be transferred to my Swiss Bank account in Zürich. Good Bye, and BE HAPPY!!!"
Of course, no one followed Ms Smarty's advice. I do not even believe that her emotional sophistry impacted on her opponents.
Attempting a Wittgenstein-style analysis to solve the semantic mess of this debate, I came to a simple conclusion:
There is a pernicious linguistic confusion about the concept of Happiness!
Money certainly makes it easier to have joyful moments, but even a huge uninterrupted series of joys cannot be confused with true happiness.
Attempting a Wittgenstein-style analysis to solve the semantic mess of this debate, I came to a simple conclusion:
There is a pernicious linguistic confusion about the concept of Happiness!
Money certainly makes it easier to have joyful moments, but even a huge uninterrupted series of joys cannot be confused with true happiness.
So this seems to be on the root of so much time wasting on those frequent wordy quarrels with the usual loss of good humor between the opponents.
Whoever takes stances on philosophical discussions, must define clearly their concepts first to speak the same language as other eventual participants.
No comments:
Post a Comment
The author looks forward to reading your comments!
O autor aguarda seus valiosos comentários, leitor.